Book Lover Mystery Box


For a complete breakdown on all our boxes and what may be featured inside your box please scroll down the page. Each Book Lover Mystery Box is completely unique and has the best bookish products inside! These boxes are what Willow packs on social media under her “Pack a Mystery Box with Me” videos.

Please note:

  • The Shipping note section at checkout is ONLY for book titles and/or merchandise you already have so we don’t give duplicates.  Pretty please do not use it as a shopping list, requests for specific items and books will not be fulfilled. If you struggle to leave a note telling us what books you already have, please Contact Us and send your note.


  • We only offer a mixture of books and merch (quantities below), all book boxes, or all merchandise boxes. Please be CLEAR when indicating to us what box you’d like!


  • Willow Winters collections can be counted as two, three or four of the boxes total books due to their size and interior quantity. Hardbacks are not included in mystery boxes.
  • Clothing is not guaranteed when leaving your size. 
  • While the books in our boxes are predominately by Willow, we do sometimes have books from other authors! Selecting that you’re happy receiving books from other authors does not mean you will only get other authors, you will receive a mixture.


  • All pictures featured on this listing show items that have been in a  Book Lover Mystery Box or may show up in yours!


Earn up to 250 Points.


Our Book Lover Mystery Box is filled with bookish goodies and the best books! We currently offer four different sizes of these boxes; Medium, Large, Extra Large and Extra, Extra Large!

  • We only offer a mixture of books and merch (quantities below), all book boxes, or all merchandise boxes. If you ask for more books, you will ONLY receive books. If you ask for mostly bookish merch you will ONLY receive merch.

Our Medium Book Mystery Box ($49.99) has TWO books and 3 merch items.

Our Large box ($99.99), you can expect TWO more paperbacks and up to 6 merch items.

Our Extra Large Box ($149.99) will have another TWO paperbacks and even more merch up to 9 items!!

Our Extra Extra Large Box (249.99) will have another paperback and is packed with the must have bookish merch up to 12 items!

If you request an ALL BOOK Box you can expect (please remember collections are counted as TWO books):

Our Medium Book Mystery Box ($49.99) – 4 books

Our Large box ($99.99), – 7 books

Our Extra Large Box ($149.99) – 10 books

Our Extra Extra Large Box (249.99) – 17 books.

If you request an ALL MERCH Box you can expect:

Our Medium Book Mystery Box ($49.99) – approx 5 bookish items

Our Large box ($99.99), – approx 9 bookish items

Our Extra Large Box ($149.99) – approx 12 bookish items

Our Extra Extra Large Box (249.99) – approx 15 bookish items

**Please note, if you already have a lot of bookish merch, we would be limited on what we could put in your box. We will try and accommodate merch requests, however please note it will change the # of items you receive. 

Our “merch items” may include anything from but not inclusive to drink ware, homeware, totes/bags, pens, accessories and even jewellery. We also, from time to time, love to include items that are perfect for those times when you’re settling down and diving into a good book which can include but again not inclusive to, self care items, bath bombs, candles and more. And we’ll often include lots of cute swag like stickers and bookmarks!

As all the boxes are different, items will vary from box to box. Please note specific requested items are not guaranteed.

*Please note: Decadent Editions will not be included in these Mystery Boxes.



Want to know more about our seasonal subscription boxes? 

Our Blue Willow Winters Mystery Boxes are also shipped seasonally and again come in two sizes. Medium and Large. These boxes are all about Willow Winters. You get all the latest Willow Winters signed paperbacks and special Willow Winters merchandise and swag! They are a Willow Winters fan favorite! To find out more about the Willow Winters Mystery Boxes, click here!


Don’t miss a thing!

We’re constantly adding new items to the shop and we don’t want you to miss any of them! So be sure to follow the Big Book Lover Shop on social media for all the latest news and product drops!

Additional information

Weight 64 oz
Dimensions 11 × 8 × 6 in

You may also like…